Wire wheel

Wire wheelswire-spoked wheelstension-spoked wheels, or “suspension” wheels are wheels whose rims connect to their hubs by wire spokes.[1][2][3] Although these wires are generally stiffer than a typical wire rope, they function mechanically the same as tensioned flexible wires, keeping the rim true while supporting applied loads. The term suspension wheel should not be confused with vehicle suspension.[3]

Wire wheels are used on most bicycles and are still used on many motorcycles. They were invented by aeronautical engineer George Cayley in 1808.[4] Although Cayley first proposed wire wheels, he did not apply for a patent. The first patent for wire wheels was issued to Theodore Jones of London, England on October 11, 1826.[5] Eugène Meyer of Paris, France was the first person to receive, in 1869, a patent for wire wheels on bicycles.[6]

Bicycle wheels were not strong enough for cars until the development of tangentially spoked wheels. They rapidly became well established in the bicycle and motor tricycle world but were not common on cars until around 1907. This was encouraged by the Rudge-Whitworth patented detachable and interchangeable wheels designed by John Pugh. These wheels owed their resistance to braking and accelerative stresses to their two inner rows of tangential spokes. An outer row of radial spokes gave lateral strength against cornering strains. These wheels were deeply dished so that steering pivot pins might lie as near as possible to the center-line of the tires. Their second feature was that they were easily detachable being mounted on splined false hubs. A process of assembling wire wheels is described as wheelbuilding.

Wire wheels on a 1929 Alfa Romeo 6C 1750 Spyder Supersport

Rudge-Whitworth wire wheel on a 1922 Vauxhall 25

Wire wheels on a 1957 MGA

On automobile

From the earliest days automobiles used either wire wheels or heavy wooden or pressed steel spoked artillery type. The development of the quick detachable hubs of either Rudge-Whitworth or Riley design did much to popularise wire wheels and incidentally led to the fitting of “spare wheels”. After their wooden spoked artillery wheels proved inadequate many US manufacturers paid John Pugh of Rudge-Whitworthroyalties to manufacture wire wheels using his patents. Artillery wheels fell out of favour in the late 1920s and the development of the cheaper pressed steel wheels by Joseph Sankey replaced wire wheels wherever the premium price of wire wheels was not justified by their weight saving.

Sports cars

Before 1960, sports/racing cars usually had Rudge-Whitworth wire wheels center-locking equipped with splined hubs and a quick-release “knockoff” (central wing nut) locking cap[note 1] that could be unscrewed by striking a wing of the nut with a special alloy mallet or “knockoff hammer”.[7] Some jurisdictions, including West Germany, prohibited eared hubcaps.  Some manufacturers (e.g. Maserati) preferred to hold the wheel on the splined hub by capping with a single conventional unwinged nut requiring a special large spanner.

In the 1960s even lighter cast alloy wheels became usual—at first with splined hubs and knock-off caps—and now predominate. New versions of wire wheels are still made but often with standard hub bolt patterns covered by a center cap to fit without adapters.

Reaction to load

The reaction to a radial load of a well-tensioned wire spoked wheel, such as by a rider sitting on a bicycle, is that the wheel flattens slightly near the ground contact area. The rest of the wheel remains approximately circular.[13][14][15][16] The tension of all the spokes does not increase significantly. Instead, only the spokes directly under the hub decrease their tension.[12][17][18][19] The issue of how best to describe this situation is debated.[20] Some authors conclude from this that the hub “stands” on those spokes immediately below it that experience a reduction in tension, even though the spokes below the hub exert no upward force on the hub and can be replaced by chains without much changing the physics of the wheel.[15][12] Other authors conclude that the hub “hangs” from those spokes above it that exert an upward force on the hub, and that have higher tension than the spokes below the hub, which pull down on the hub.[18][21]

Despite being composed of thin and relatively flexible spokes, wire wheels are radially stiff and provide very little suspension compliance compared to even high-pressure bicycle tires.[22][23][24][25]

Note

  1. 1.3.4 Wire wheels
    The center-lock wire wheel is traditionally associated with vintage sports cars and racing cars, and for those of us of advancing years the blood is still stirred by memories of split-seconds saved by the deft application of copper-headed hammers to eared hubcaps. We also remember… page 5, Colin Campbell New Directions in Suspension Design: Making the Fast Car Faster Taylor & Francis, 1981, USA. ISBN 0-8376-0150-9.

References

  1. Forester, John (August 1980). “Held Up By Downward Pull”. American Wheelmen. Retrieved 2012-06-26how the tension spoked wheel carries its load
  2. Brown, Sheldon. “Bicycle Tires and Tubes, How a Tire Supports its Load”. Retrieved 2012-06-26The tension-spoked wheel and the pneumatic tire are two examples of what are called preloaded tensile structures, brilliant, counterintuitive designs working together remarkably to support as much as 100 times their own weight.
  3. a b C. S. Walker (1920). “Wire Wheels”. Society of Automotive Engineers. pp. 425–432. Retrieved 2012-06-26As the wire wheel is a “suspension” wheel, the car weight is hung or “cradled” from scores of resilient, flexible spokes.
  4. In his notebook, dated March 19, 1808, Cayley proposed that in order to produce “the lightest possible wheel for aerial navigation cars,” one should “do away with wooden spokes altogether and refer the whole firmness of the wheel to the strength of the rim only, by the intervention of tight strong cording … ” See: J.A.D. Ackroyd (2011) “Sir George Cayley: The invention of the aeroplane near Scarborough at the time of Trafalgar,” Journal of Aeronautical History [Internet publication], paper no. 6, pages 130-181. Cayley’s tension-spoke wheel appears on page 152, “3.7 The Tension Wheel, 1808”.
  5. See:
    • Notice of Theodore Jones’ patent for wire wheels: Repertory of patent inventions, etc., no. 17 (November 1826), page 320.
    • Illustrations and description of Jones’ wire wheel: Luke Hebert, ed. (April 20, 1828) “Patent suspension wheels,” The Register of Arts, and Journal of Patent Inventions, 2nd series, 2 (29) : pages 65-66.
  6. Bulletin des lois de la République française (1873) 12th series, vol. 6, page 648, patent no. 86,705: “Perfectionnements dans les roues de vélocipèdes” (Improvements in the wheels of bicycles), issued: 4 August 1869.
  7. Wilson McComb. “Principles of the Centre-Lock Wire Wheel”. Retrieved 2013-05-18Let us take a closer look at this assembly, referring to the central portion of the wheel as the “wheel center”, which is fitted to the “hub” and fixed in place with a ‘locking cap’.
  8. Herlihy, David V (2004). Bicycle: the History. Yale University Press. pp. 141–142. ISBN 0-300-10418-9.
  9.  McConnell, Anita (2004). “Stanley, William Ford Robinson (1829–1909)”. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (subscription required – free to holders of tickets for British libraries). Oxford University Press. Retrieved 9 September 2009.
  10.  Owen, W.B. (1912). Sir Sidney Lee, ed. Dictionary of National Biography – William Ford Robinson Stanley. Second Supplement. III (Neil-Young). London: Smith, Elder & Co.pp. 393–394.
  11.  “Good week to go for ride”. The Croydon Guardian. 10 June 2006. Retrieved 9 September 2009.
  12.  b c Brandt, Jobst (1981). The Bicycle Wheel. Avocet. pp. 12–20. ISBN 0-9607236-2-5.
  13.  Forester, John (August 1980). “Held Up By Downward Pull”. American Wheelmen.
  14.  Whitt, Frank R.; David G. Wilson (1982). Bicycling Science (Second ed.). Massachusetts Institute of Technology. pp. 106–138. ISBN 0-262-23111-5.
  15.  b Ian Smith. “Bicycle Wheel Analysis”. Retrieved 2008-12-31I conclude that it is perfectly reasonable to say that the hub stands on the lower spokes, and that it does not hang from the upper spokes.
  16.  C.J. Burgoyne and R. Dilmaghanian (March 1993). “Bicycle Wheel as Prestressed Structure” (pdf). Journal of Engineering Mechanics119 (3): 439–455. doi:10.1061/(asce)0733-9399(1993)119:3(439). ISSN 0733-9399. Only the spokes in contact with the ground, or near the ground, show significant strains.
  17.  Wilson, David Gordon; Jim Papadopoulos (2004). Bicycling Science (Third ed.). Massachusetts Institute of Technology. pp. 389–390. ISBN 0-262-73154-1.
  18.  b Tom Fine (September 1998). “Hubs hang from the rim!”. Retrieved 2010-03-16I still say, without any doubt, that the hub hangs from the upper spokes.
  19.  Henri P. Gavin (August 1996). “Bicycle Wheel Spoke Patterns and Spoke Fatigue” (pdf). ASCE Journal of Engineering Mechanics122 (8): 736–742. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9399(1996)122:8(736).
  20.  Kraig Willett (5 September 2004). “Hang or Stand?”. BikeTech Review. Retrieved 2010-03-16A little known semantic debate … has been raging on the usenet newsgroups for quite some time. The point of contention in this debate is whether or not a loaded bicycle wheel “stands” on the bottom spokes or “hangs” from the top ones?
  21.  Samuel K. Clark, V. E. Gough (1981). Mechanics of Pneumatic Tires. U.S. Department of Transportation. p. 241. The system of load transmission is analogous to that of a cycle wheel where the hub hangs by the steel wire spokes from the top of the rim, which is loaded at the bottom.
  22.  John Swanson (2006). “Performance of the Bicycle Wheel, A Method for Analysis”(PDF). BikePhysics.com. Retrieved 2012-06-25Radial Stiffness: There’s almost -no- vertical compliance in your wheel and people who insist that they can feel the vertical stiffness or “harshness” of a wheel are mistaken. The radial stiffness of a bicycle wheel is ~ 3-4000 N/mm. This equals a deflection of 0.1 mm under a 40 kg load. Sorry princess, but that gets obscured by the amount of deflection in the tires, fork, saddle, handlebar tape, frame, and even your gloves.
  23.  Henri P. Gavin (1996). “Bicycle Wheel Spoke Patterns and Spoke Fatigue” (PDF). ASCE Journal of Engineering Mechanics. Retrieved 2012-06-25radial wheel stiffness (N/mm): 2500-5000
  24.  Ian (2002). “Spoke Patterns”. astounding.org.uk. Retrieved 2012-06-25A radially spoked wheel is about 4.6% stiffer than a tangentially spoked one. Alternatively, if you apply 1000N (about 100kg, 220lb) to each of the wheels, the tangential (four-cross) spoked one deflects 0.0075mm (0.0003 inch) more than the radial spoked. Since the tyre is likely to deflect several millimetres at least (if 3mm, that’s 400 times more deflection) I conclude the spoking is unlikely to make a discernible difference to the vertical stiffness of the wheel.
  25.  Jobst Brandt (1981). “Sheldon Brown’s Bicycle Glossary: Radial spoking”. Sheldon Brown (bicycle mechanic). Retrieved 2012-06-25There is no change in radial elasticity between a radial and crossed spoke wheel with the same components, other than the length of the spokes. A 290 mm spoke is 3% stiffer than a 300 mm spoke of the same type. Since spokes stretch elastically about 0.1mm on a hard bump (not ordinary road ripples), the elastic difference between the radial and cross-three wheel is 3% x 0.1mm = 0.003 mm. Copier paper is 0.075 mm thick, and if you can feel that when you ride over it on a glassy smooth concrete surface, please let me know. You have greater sensitivity than the lady in “the princess and the pea” fable.
Tweel The Tweel (a portmanteau of tire and wheel) is an airless tire design concept developed by the French tire company Michelin. Its significant advantage over pneumatic tires is that the Tweel does not use a bladder full of compressed air, and therefore it cannot burst, leak pressure, or become flat. Instead, the Tweel assembly's inner hub connects to flexible polyurethane spokes which are used to support an outer rim and these engineered compliant components assume the shock-absorbing role provided by the compressed air in a traditional tire. The Tweel airless tire design Design The Tweel consists of a band of conventional tire rubber with molded tread, a shear beam just below the tread that creates a compliant contact patch, a series of energy-absorbing polyurethane spokes, and an integral inner rim structure. Both the shear beam and the polyurethane spokes can be designed to provide a calibrated directional stiffness in order that design engineers are able to control both how th...
Alloy wheel In the automotive industry, alloy wheels are wheels that are made from an alloy of aluminium or magnesium. Alloys are mixtures of a metal and other elements. They generally provide greater strength over pure metals, which are usually much softer and more ductile. Alloys of aluminium or magnesium are typically lighter for the same strength, provide better heat conduction, and often produce improved cosmetic appearance over steel wheels. Although steel, the most common material used in wheel production, is an alloy of iron and carbon, the term "alloy wheel" is usually reserved for wheels made from nonferrous alloys. The earliest light-alloy wheels were made of magnesium alloys. Although they lost favor on common vehicles, they remained popular through the 1960s, albeit in very limited numbers. In the mid-to-late 1960s, aluminum-casting refinements allowed the manufacture of safer wheels that were not as brittle. Until this time, most aluminum wheels suffered from low ductility, usuall...
Rim (wheel) The rim is the "outer edge of a wheel, holding the tire". It makes up the outer circular design of the wheel on which the inside edge of the tire is mounted on vehicles such as automobiles. For example, on a bicycle wheel the rim is a large hoop attached to the outer ends of the spokes of the wheel that holds the tire and tube. The term rim is also used non-technically to refer to the entire wheel, or even to a tire. In the 1st millennium BC, an iron rim was introduced around the wooden wheels of chariots. Cross section of a bicycle rim wooden bicycle rim with tubular tyre Characteristics Scratched rim on two-piece wheel. Black residue remaining from where the tire was seated on the "safety profile" rim. Diameter (effective): distance between the bead seats (for the tire), as measured in the plane of the rim and through the axis of the hub which is or will be attached, or which is integral with the rim. Width (e...
Magnesium wheels Magnesium wheels are wheels manufactured from alloys which contain mostly magnesium. Magnesium wheels are produced either by casting (metalworking) (where molten metal is introduced into a mold, solidifying within the mold), or by forging (where a prefabricated bar is deformed mechanically). Magnesium has several key properties that make it an attractive base metal for wheels: lightness; a high damping capacity; and a high specific strength. Magnesium is the lightest metallic structural material available. It is 1.5 times less dense than aluminium, so magnesium wheels can be designed to be significantly lighter than aluminium alloy wheels, while exhibiting comparable strength. All competitive racing rims are now made of magnesium alloy. Cast magnesium wheels Taking into account their generally inferior quality compared to forged wheels, the main advantage of cast wheels is the relatively low cost of production. And although cast wheels are more affordable than forged wheels, cast...
Wheel A wheel is a circular component that is intended to rotate on an axle bearing. The wheel is one of the key components of the wheel and axle which is one of the six simple machines. Wheels, in conjunction with axles, allow heavy objects to be moved easily facilitating movement or transportation while supporting a load, or performing labor in machines. Wheels are also used for other purposes, such as a ship's wheel, steering wheel, potter's wheel and flywheel. Common examples are found in transport applications. A wheel greatly reduces friction by facilitating motion by rolling together with the use of axles. In order for wheels to rotate, a moment needs to be applied to the wheel about its axis, either by way of gravity or by the application of another external force or torque. Using the wheel, Sumerians invented a contraption that spins clay as a potter shapes it into the desired object. Three wheels on an antique tricycle The earliest wheels were m...